FOX Sports Ranks Bills' Josh Allen Over Patrick Mahomes as NFL's Best QB

August 24, 2026 - 17:42

The debate over who truly is the best quarterback in the NFL just got a lot hotter. FOX Sports analysts have released their latest positional rankings, and they have Buffalo Bills signal-caller Josh Allen sitting at the top of the list, ahead of Kansas City Chiefs superstar Patrick Mahomes. That is a bold call, considering Mahomes has three Super Bowl rings and has been the league's gold standard for years.

The reasoning behind the move is not about past trophies, though. The analysts point to Allen's unique combination of arm strength, rushing ability, and sheer physical dominance. They argue that no other quarterback can single-handedly take over a game the way Allen does when he is at his peak. His ability to break tackles, extend plays, and throw from impossible angles makes him a nightmare for any defense. Add in his improved decision-making last season, and the FOX Sports crew believes he has officially surpassed Mahomes as the most complete player at the position.

Of course, Mahomes still has the playoff resume and the clutch gene. But the rankings seem to focus on raw talent and overall impact rather than team success. Allen has carried a Bills roster that often lacked elite weapons, while Mahomes has benefited from a strong supporting cast and a genius head coach in Andy Reid. That context matters when evaluating individual greatness.

The reaction has been split. Bills fans are celebrating, while Chiefs fans are pointing to the trophy case. Either way, the conversation is far from over. With the new season approaching, both quarterbacks will have every chance to settle the argument on the field. For now, FOX Sports has made its pick, and it is a fascinating one.